
Though several black film directors look to him as a mentor in Hollywood, Spike Lee hasn't been too pleased with Tinsletown's most successful black filmmaker of the day, Tyler Perry.
Lee has been very vocal about his frustration with the images of black America shown in some of Perry's films, saying, "We shouldn't think that Tyler Perry is going to make the same film that I am going to make...but at the same time, for me, the imaging is troubling and harkens back to 'Amos n' Andy.'"
In response to the criticism, Perry told a '60 Minutes' reporter that Lee's comments "pissed him off" and were "insulting" because he creates all of his characters as "bait to get people talking about God, love, family and faith."
Despite them appearing to be polar opposites, both filmmaking icons have more than just a few things in common.
BlackVoices.com explores how both acclaimed directors have proved themselves to be viable commodities – helping to break the careers of new talent, while transforming and resurrecting the careers of other legendary actors -- all the while becoming their own men and unapologetically making the types of films they are passionate about.
But there's more.
Check out a tale of the titans.



Comments: (58)
Add a comment
By: rhonda on 11/06/2010 3:43PM
It's hard to get Hollywood to
agree to do a quality film with our faces.
Hollywood figures we only want to see Tyler Perry type films. Not all of us do. But Hollywood thinks we do and so they are not green lighting anything for us. Their answer is "let Tyler Perry do the Black films since he has his own studio."
Which is too bad because Tyler Perry's perspective on movies and life is different from another Director's.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Pott54 on 11/10/2010 4:32PM
HOLLYWOOD isn't LETTING TYLER PERRY DO ANYTHING. Tyler Perry doesn't even work out of HOLLYWOOD--his massive studio is in ATLANTA much to the chagrin of Hollywood executives.
So typical of "knee-grows" like you to give white folks credit for anything and everything African-Americans do. HOLLYWOOD hasn't BANKROLLED one Tyler Perry Project--he finances all of his projects himself or in conjunction with others like Oprah Winfrey.
This man has worked long and hard and has invested his OWN money to do what he does. By writing and producing his own plays for the African-American dispora, he has created a movie DEMOGRAPHIC of HIS OWN--not one developed by Hollywood.
I'm glad that African-Americans like Tyler Perry DON'T HAVE YOUR MENTALITY. We'd still be whistling Dixie while picking cotton & thanking "massah" for "LETTING" US DO IT - LOL!
Thank God for Tyler, Oprah and yes Spike.
Report This
By: va's finest on 11/06/2010 4:12PM
Negro please!
Regardless of color, Spike Lee has no right to criticize ANYBODY'S work! He has not ALWAYS portrayed colored people in the best light either. (eg. She's gottta have it, School days, Mo' Better Blues, Do the right thing, hell any of his films w/ the exception of Malcom X, which was more of a documentary)
Bottom line, Spike's films, while the intention to she d light on some relevant issues in the black community, Spike takes so long to make a point that most viewers lose focus and/or interest.
Tighten up brother! Frankly, I am sick of him criticizing everyone else when he has yet to become the iconic director that he has "self appointed" himself to be.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: wb7ptr on 11/06/2010 4:30PM
I just watched the Trailer for Miracle at St. Anna ... think I'm going to put that one on my Netflix rental list! Looks like a really good film, and didn't know Spike Lee did much in the way of drama like that. The material in the trailer was really well done ... I look forward to seeing that one.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: JudiBelle on 11/06/2010 4:48PM
We are our biggest enemy. Going back to what my Mom use to say,"If you have nothing nice to say about the person, then say nothing." We always find it necessary to air our ill feelings about each other in public. Then we wonder where people get these sterotypes that Blacks don't get along. We don't support one another. Well, very often
sadly enough some of these issues are true and require our attention for improvement.Fact-Both men are creative, talented individuals. Fact- Both filmakers did a lot to employ actors of color that Hollywood wouldn't employ. Fact- Both men worked hard,struggled over came obstacles to be in the successful seat they occupy today! So , lets stop the name calling, the negative remarks and be a role model for our youngsters!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tiff on 11/06/2010 7:19PM
Both men are talented. I think Lee being a New Yorker, naturally has a more in your face, tough look on things in life. Perry, has his own way of looking at issues in the Black community in a way that appeals to more women and older people. For people to say that Lee has no relevance is crazy. Lee's work is Oscar nominated and his work that debuted on HBO, "When the Leeves Broke", was superb. I would love to see them work together on a piece of work and combine their styles to create a masterpiece!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: just on 11/06/2010 8:17PM
blackvoices is getting just as ignorant as racist media..and folks are buying into it.
I'll always be a Spike fan. Tyler gets a larger 1 dimensional brain dead audience because they want to be entertained and not edu-tained.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Ruth A 74 year old who loves TPs' movies on 11/06/2010 9:02PM
Sounds more like your brain. Have you ever heard It is better to keep you mouth close and let people think you are a fool, than to open you mouth and prove it.
Report This
By: sabrina on 11/06/2010 9:00PM
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
wacksploitation.blogspot.com
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: ooo-b-doo on 11/06/2010 8:55PM
I like them both. Keep it rolling tyler Perry. Your films had me down on my knees lMAO and then there was plenty of insight that people could relate to. I like all the other Black Producers too, and the actors. Keep it real, and keep on putting good stuff out there.
Reply to this Comment | Report This